Rss Feed

welcome to my space

Twilight/New Moon/Eclipse: Edward or Jacob? Who would you choose?

March 11th, 2010 by , under nnmj.com.

  • I would personally choose Edward...he has honestly captured my heart...and he is just so perfect


  • I would choose Jacob. Edward is perfect but he's TOO perfect. He's so perfect it would just annoy me after awhile.

    Jacob is your average guy (almost a human Edward). He's funny, cool, fun, mysterious...I also love that he fought for Bella. So sweet *tear*


  • EDWARD EDWARD EDWARD!!! edward is not perfect in every way... which almost makes him even more perfect. Hello!!!??? he left Bella because he thought it would be better for her---- then she gets so depressed she is practically suicidal!!! but still edward had good intentions, he WAS trying to help. Report Abuse


  • Edward because her perfect and hes he hottttt!!!!! but he has the hole 'don't care if you see some one you love and he ove you' jealous. And jaccob is to young and he is so bigheaded.


  • ...me continued (5)...
    fault because jacob was like "if u don't prove u love me (and the only way u can do that is by asking me to kiss u) then i'm gonna leave to go fight and probably die". what an ***! (excuse my language). then i know this happens in the fourth book "Breaking Dawn", but i need to Report Abuse


  • EDWARD obviously!!! hes just soooo perfect! he loves her with all his "heart" lol.

    he loves her so much that if she wud choose jacob he wud let her go ..

    nd jacob is just a fuckn asss!! eeeh i hte him! i hope he dies ..
    ok well jacob hes not doin that .. hes theyr lik a fuckn magner that wont let go ..


    EDWARD HAS CAPTURED MY HEART!!!!!!!!


    E & B for ever!! [[ edward nd barbara duh<3 hahha]]


  • ...me continued 8...
    situation to recover from!!! ahhh! he is so stupid and then he is all like "it causes bella pain to be around humans???... oh doy im dumb"!~~~~ now really after all of those reasons how could anyone possibly like jacob, plus i didn't even mention any of the reason to pick edward Report Abuse


  • ... me continued ...
    then he realizes his mistake and he feels so incredibly bad!! then there is jacob who is trying to seduce bella! he kissed her and when she tried to get him off of her she broke his hand, but for some odd reason her pulling his hair was "her encouraging him"... Report Abuse


  • I would defiantly choose Edward. He is so loving, caring, protective, and perfect. Edward is the best vampire ever.


  • I would choose edward. Who wouldn't it? He is the perfect guy.


  • ...me continued 7...
    and ditches his pack (well for good reason but still i hate him)... and when rennesmee is born he imprints on her! how dare he! JERK!!! and then he decides to continue being an dumb-a.s.s and phases in front of charlie!!! WTF!!! grrrr he leaves the cullens with an impossible... Report Abuse


  • Edward.
    I have never liked Jacob, and can't see how Bella could love him. He's a horrible person (and a dog, but that is my own personal prejudices) and he doesn't accept Edward at all. Edward DOES accept Jacob, even if he doesn't like him. I forgave Edward for leaving Bella in New Moon, but him being gone and me having to spend the whole bloody book with JACOB drove me nuts.
    Eclipse is MUCH better.... But, anyway....
    Yes, Edward. He's just a wonderful, wonderful person.... I wish I could have my own! I'd even let in all the near-death experiences if I could have an Edward, as long as he never left and Jacob was gone!


  • I'm not sure which I would choose Edward would be perfect but so would Jacob. Edward because he can be really great most of the time and his abilities; his looks are ok but not really what i would choose. Jacob because he can also be a really great person most of the time; he's always so happy; his looks are the best out of the two


  • yes exactly, you are just like everyone else. blinded by edward's perfect face and super abilities!!
    jacob, duh. i mean, he's so awesome. and edward is such a annoying twit. in New Moon, he leaves bella, then in Eclipse, he doesn't let her see jacob, even though not seeing him is really hurting her, as he knows!!! he is so annoying!! and so overprotective!!! arghhh. i am so mad that everyone loves him so much just because he looks perfect, and just because he said like one funny thing. he is always saying cheesy things, and that is just totally annoying and jacob, like, WARNED bella when he was going to say something cheesy. come on, get a life, edward.


  • ..me continued 10..
    and if u still pick jacob over edward explain to me y! and jacob is not an "average guy" he turns into a worlf when he looses his tepmer and edward is not "too perfect" jeez JACOB IS NOT A GOOD PERSON EVER! ahhh! EDWARD!! forever edward no jacob plus jacob looses anyway so to bad Report Abuse


  • ...me continued (6)...
    go into further detail about why jacob sucks!!!: jacob then leaves and comes back at bella and edwards wedding (only because edward asked him to for bella---how sweet of EDWARD) and tries to get involved with their life and causes a huge scene... then jacob goes all alpha... Report Abuse


  • Edward. Jacob annoys me way too much but Edward is perfect.


  • ...me continued (3)...
    jacob has serious issues! and then edward doesn't want bella to be around jacob because he is dangerous (and don't say he isn't because u know what sam did to emily). then edward feels bad and lets jacob see bella and he totally takes advantage of her! and still his diguisting Report Abuse


  • ...me continued (4)...
    thoughts are torturing poor edward! he doesn't deserve that! and then jacob has the NERVE to taunt edward even more by getting in a sleeping bag with bella and expanding his repulsive thoughts! NASTY!!! and then stupid stupid bella kissed jacob, but really i wasn't even her... Report Abuse


  • ...me continued 9...
    hello!! so many reason to be in love with edward and i don't feel it is nessessary to list them but if u need me to just email me (vollyballqueen5@yahoo.com)... and jacob is a freaking shape-shipfter (he isn't even a wearwolf... so yah... please after reading all of my comment.. Report Abuse


  • Edward. He is just such a classically romantic figure of a guy. The reason we are all in love with him is becuz he embodies everything we women like in our men. Brains, beauty, strength, heart, mystery & a sense of danger. All women are attracted to these things so that's what makes him so appealing to us all. I think he is really a great character & I can't wait to read his side of the story in "Midnight Sun".







  • #If you have any other info about this subject , Please add it free.#
    Your name:
    E-mail:
    Telphone:

    Your comments:


    If you have any other info about Twilight/New Moon/Eclipse: Edward or Jacob? Who would you choose? , Please add it free.